Путь прокладывается под ногами идущего. Главный принцип жизни
By гenesis?
Summary
Topics Covered
- New Motives Emerge From Activity, Not Innate Needs
- Fame Cannot Satisfy an Unmet Need for Self-Assertion
- Happiness Is a Motive, Not a Goal
- Adventure Stories Shift Focus From Treasure to Means
- Jokes Work by Moving One Element Through Two Contexts
Full Transcript
And then we will do the following.
On this question, yes.
For the sake of order, I will say again that we have three definitions of action .
The first definition is that an action is a process where the motive and the goal do not coincide.
The second is that an action is a process subordinated to a conscious goal .
And the third is that an action is a process of solving problems, involving goal formation and the search for means .
And now, having said that the action is the central level of activity, perhaps in this question we will now examine the relationship between
activity and actions.
And in the next, third question, we will examine the relationship between actions and operations.
So, action and activity, or the problem of the emergence of new motives.
You know, there is an age-old problem.
Where do new needs come from?
What are their sources?
Before Leontiev, this problem could be solved by saying all these sources are innate.
Well, and then it becomes a little unclear how even collecting match labels or stamps, or something similar, has its own source.
We will not argue with this traditional point of view.
It is important for me to explain a different point of view.
The source of new motives is in itself, or rather, in the structure of the activity itself.
The source of new motives is located in the structure of the activity itself.
Where exactly?
For now, it may seem unclear, but then there will be three examples.
At the level of actions.
And you know, this topic does not require much theorizing.
I will provide either two or three examples.
Example one.
Let's call it this.
Changing the leading activity.
Changing the leading activity, or from play to learning.
Changing the leading activity, or from play to learning.
We can put a semicolon and write it like this.
The goal acquires the functions of a motive.
The goal acquires the functions of a motive.
You probably know, and if not, you will learn about it later, that in developmental psychology, leading
activities are identified.
If there are leading motives, it means there are also leading activities.
I will not list them completely.
I will name, for the sake of order, say , a friend and colleague of Alexei Nikolaevich Leontiev, Daniil Borisovich
Elkonin.
He identifies these leading activities as follows: infancy, emotional communication with the mother; early
childhood, manipulation of objects.
Finally, older preschool childhood, as we already said today, make-believe play .
Make-believe play. And the younger schoolchild?
For the younger schoolchild, the leading activity is learning.
And then let's look, after all, the change of the leading activity is, generally speaking, a crisis, a change of motives.
And how does this change from play to learning occur?
You know, one of the, in my opinion, good experiments in our country was when elements of learning began to be introduced in kindergartens, and in
primary school classes they often resorted to play methods.
That is, there is an opportunity to make this transition less painful.
But we will consider this transition in principle.
And we consider it like this.
Here is the activity of a preschooler.
Its motive is mastering a future social role.
Mastering a future social role.
Moreover, one can switch roles and act out plots.
There are more or less attractive roles , and so on.
That is, the preschooler is learning how to interact.
What actions do they perform in the process?
There can be a whole range of actions.
For example, sewing some costume for a game, and learning those very same rules of interaction.
But the main thing is that among these actions there will necessarily be learning actions.
One must learn the rules, and one must follow these rules.
For this, learning actions are necessary .
What is happening gradually?
What happens to a child when they enter school?
Of course, with the participation of an adult.
Leontiev spoke about this in different ways, but I, perhaps, would say it like this.
That which was a goal— to study, to learn something—that which was a goal acquires the power of a motive.
To study for the sake of studying itself .
To study for the sake of the process of learning itself.
And what happened to the game?
The game disappeared, but not entirely.
It, the game, changed its place.
Studying has now become the activity, and the game has taken the place of actions.
Action and activity have swapped places .
And what was previously a goal has become a motive.
Example two.
The emergence of anomalous needs, or the shift of motive to goal.
The emergence of anomalous needs, or the shift of motive to goal.
This very phrase of Leontiev’s, "shift of motive to goal," has drawn a great deal of criticism.
And I am taking a bit of a risk when I tell you the following. The shift of motive to goal—this mechanism can be
shown very well using the example of anomalous needs.
Not just any, but negative needs.
And once again, we will take the same example—well, let’s say, the negative need for alcohol dependence.
In our country, there are quite a few excellent specialists on this topic.
But I would cite a literary work here for us, because in a literary work, the problem is presented more vividly.
The work is called*John Barleycorn*.
The author is Jack London.
Someone might tell us that this work is at least somewhat autobiographical, but that is not so important for us.
It is important to us that indeed in this work, as in many other works by Jack London, for example, in his novel* Martin Eden*, we are talking about a
writer.
This is a famous writer.
And he clearly suffers from the aforementioned addiction.
It starts right there—or rather, to say "suffers from an addiction" is probably a medical term.
It is better to say that for him, this is an activity.
For him, this is an activity, and the corresponding actions are filled with meaning.
For example, he calculates how much text , literary text, how many pages he must write in the morning before allowing
himself a drop of alcohol.
This is an elaborate activity. How did
this need arise?
And the author gives us the history of this writer.
The fact is that as a young man...
This man left home early and became quite independent; he started working at the port.
A young man working at the port.
His motive.
Excuse me, his motive can probably be called a purely Adlerian one—to occupy a full-fledged place in society.
And not a playful one, like an older preschooler, but a full-fledged place in society.
And so, in order to be one of the guys at the port, you have to, forgive me, perform a whole series of actions.
For example, train physical strength, haul heavy sacks, probably fight on Sundays, or, I don't know, maybe on Saturdays.
Although, I might not know some details here.
Getting drunk half to death.
This is a necessary action to become one of the guys at the port.
You know, even a non-psychologist will immediately understand everything.
So, at some point, he got drunk in order to occupy a full-fledged social place.
And that's it, he ruined his body.
And the psychologist will say more.
And the psychologist will say: and, apparently, a shift of motive to the goal occurred because, in fact, that
first motive of self-affirmation was not realized.
You can trust Jack London or not, but one thing is certain.
If this writer still suffers from a need for alcohol, it means his fame is not enough for him .
It means his self-affirmation did not happen.
And, forgive me, I think I talked last time about who Vysotsky was.
And then, you can't leave words out of a song.
Well, of course, Vladimir Semyonovich suffered from this illness.
And what kind?
For what reasons? For purely social reasons.
He wasn't accepted where he wanted to be .
He wasn't accepted into the Union of Soviet Writers. He never became a member
Soviet Writers. He never became a member .
He became something much greater, but he was a man of his time. He was an ordinary Soviet man.
And when now, well, soon in ninety-eight , on January 25th, he would have been 60 , surely there will be new programs,
surely there will be new memories of Vysotsky.
But once, about 10 years ago, a certain poet speaks out, whose name I would not like to mention, and says—we loved Volodya so much, he
was one of our own, we took him to France for our concert.
And the fact that half of Paris came to listen to Vysotsky, and not these strange poets, and then, forgive me, you can't leave words out of a song.
I don't know how to say it more delicately, but I am obliged to say something.
And, probably, in family life, just not in its intimate side.
There were problems here too, because, forgive me, a wife who loved her husband could not have written exactly such a
book about him.
One must know how to keep a secret; one must, in a good and kind sense, keep certain things hidden.
Although nothing harms the glory of a genius, we have nonetheless provided an example of shifting a motive to a goal.
Shall I make you laugh a little?
Yes.
You are brave people.
Our goal is communism. What is that?
It is a shift of motive to a goal.
This is an example of shifting a motive to a goal.
I probably told you that, as a Pioneer, I greeted the 22nd Party Congress.
And therefore, I have the right to say, look, it included peace, labor, freedom , equality, brotherhood, and happiness for all peoples.
What is happiness?
Can happiness be a goal?
Happiness is a motive.
And the Russian poet Pushkin said—there is no happiness in the world, only peace and freedom.
If they had written "our goal is peace and freedom," Pushkin would say, "No, our goal is happiness."
And you know, what kind of meaning—or rather, nonsense—the people who wrote this committed.
There is an experiment described by Leontiev in his last book, "Activity, Consciousness Personality."
Consciousness Personality." When an electrode is implanted into a rat's pleasure center, it can deliver happiness to itself with its own hand.
Actually, not a hand, excuse me, a paw.
And so it drives itself to super-happiness and dies.
This is exactly—you know, to put it carefully and without jokes—a state of voluntary activity, where a person
creates and is truly at least a small hero, which has been confused with an involuntary state.
I will definitely give more examples of such small heroes, but today I will finish with this.
The first example was how we transitioned from play to learning.
The second example was how pathogenic needs are formed.
And you know, let's not number them, but just in case, here is a third example.
This mechanism of shifting a motive to a goal is used, widely used, in stimulating creativity.
And this mechanism is called—change the context.
Change of context.
How is an adventure novel created? How
is a soap opera created?
By changing the context.
When you explain to your younger brothers and sisters what you are taught in the first year of the psychology department, and what these tricky words "shift of motive to a goal" mean.
Look with them at the book "Treasure Island."
Island." What is the motive there from the very beginning?
The treasure.
The motive is the treasure.
And the map leading to it.
And in order to carry out this extensive activity, a whole series of actions had to be performed.
Buying a yacht—a schooner, rather, right ? A schooner, hiring a crew, and so on
? A schooner, hiring a crew, and so on and so forth.
And excuse me, but an adventure novel is such that now we are interested in these actions themselves.
They have long since become the activity .
And whether there was a treasure, like " was there even a boy," is no longer so, not so interesting.
The generation of anecdotes.
You will be, I mean we are behaving well as it is, but next time, if you want, ask me at the end how to generate jokes .
It is done exactly the same way, by shifting the motive to the goal, but only through a double shift.
It turns out that a person, who lived at the beginning of the century, only needed to change the context once.
And he would smile.
But a person of the end of the century, like us, well, perhaps needs it twice.
However, I have intrigued you, and I won't be able to start with another topic anyway, so I will spend two minutes now on this question: how, strictly speaking, a joke is constructed
.
Take a look at the drawings of Herluf Bidstrup.
What is the point? There is an element, which must be transferred from one situation to another.
So, let's look at the sequence of the drawings.
A sailor’s cabin, where sailors are chatting about something, saying certain words.
In the sailor’s cabin, there is a parrot sitting in a cage.
The initial situation.
The next situation. The parrot is being sold.
A sailor sells the parrot to an old lady .
And in the next situation, that very cherished word from the sailor's cabin jumps once.
The parrot says this word, the old lady is horrified.
Some of us smiled.
We smiled at the distant beginning of the century, but that is not enough for us.
And so they draw us another picture, where the old lady has guests, and the parrot sits sullenly in the cage and is silent.
The old lady says the word.
The guests are horrified.
That is how our element jumped twice, and now we have, so to speak, fully smiled.
And let’s note, a change of context is, first and foremost, a search for motivational reserves.
A search for transforming the situation .
And so, for next time, let us simply mark the question that interests us.
Actions and operations.
Actions and operations.
Full stop.
Types of operations.
Actions and operations. Types of
operations.
Psychophysiological functions.
Psychophysiological functions.
And after the full stop, levels of movement construction.
Levels of movement construction.
That will be the third question.
And next time I will try to ensure that both the sixth topic is finished and the main part of the seventh is covered.
Thank you for your attention.
Loading video analysis...