CoilDesigner Demonstration
By Optimized Thermal Systems, Inc.
Summary
Topics Covered
- Finite Control Volume Methodology Divides Heat Exchangers into Discrete Segments
- Correlation Selection Defines Prediction Accuracy
- Airflow Distribution Non-Uniformity Accounted Through Velocity Profiles
- Parametric Analysis Evaluates Thousands of Design Combinations
Full Transcript
you you you you you you you you you
you you you you you you you you you
you you you you you you you you
you you you you you you you you you
you you you you you you you you
you you you you you you you you you
you you you you you you you you
you you you you you you you you
all right good afternoon everyone thanks for your patience and thanks for joining it looks like most of our attendees have joined at this point so I think I'll go ahead and get started
again just a reminder if you'll please keep your microphones muted during the presentation and I will try to answer
some questions towards the end of the meeting which if you if you don't mind I'd prefer to have submitted through the chat feature within goto meeting so if
you send a chat with your questions at any point during this session I can we can discuss those towards the end of the meeting or follow up afterwards so my
name is Dennis Masuda and the engineering manager at optimized thermal systems and today we're just going to go through a brief demonstration of our
coil designer software this is really just a basic overview of the capabilities of the software and a demonstration of some applications of
how the tool can be used for any interested new users you should be able to see my screen right now which I'm
sharing with the group and I'm going to walk through just a demo of the application of the software before I begin just a bit of introduction I want
to just briefly describe optimized thermal systems and quele designer for those of you who aren't familiar I suspect that most of our guests today
have become familiar with with OTS through our webinar series that we hosted with the International copper association over the last few months and the purpose of this session is really to
give a little bit more background on our coil designer software but by way of introduction optimized thermal systems
is a company a consulting company that grows out of the research that was been conducted and continually conducted at the University of Maryland College Park and their center for environmental
energy engineering this department has developed some state-of-the-art tools for modeling heat exchangers and vapour compression systems and out of that work
several commercial software packages have been developed which OTS has the
licensing agreement to to distribute so the total I'm going to be showing today is called coil designer this is a tool
that OTS distributes commercially uses for consulting work and has licensing rights to customize for our customers as well and the purpose of the tool is
really for the simulation of heat exchangers both tube and fin micro channel as well as some coaxial heat exchanger types and a few other variants
so I'll show so with that I'll go ahead and get started with the demonstration up on my screen right now you should be
able to see the blank coil designer window before I've started any work and I'm going to go ahead and walk through
the process of creating a model for tubing fin heat exchanger so I'll start by going to file and new and this will
start up a new coil wizard which will walk me through the steps to configure a heat exchanger that I can then use for simulations as I start walking through
the steps of this in this process the software will ask me which types of heat exchanger I'd like to model and here you can see the capabilities within coil designer so for this example I'll focus
on a tube in fin heat exchanger but we also have the ability to simulate a microchannel heat exchanger coils with flat tubes wire spinning to impede
exchanger and so called coaxial tube in tube heat exchanger and after I go through this demonstration if we have time I can also demonstrate the micro
channel interface as well but one of the nice things about the software is that all of these heat exchanger types can be modeled through a very similar process through the same user interface so the
process that we show here for the tubing fan coil will be very much the same for the other coil types so with this selected I go into the basic setup of
the solver and the model of this coil first I have to choose the type of solver and the default here is the fast solver this is typically recommended for
most of our simulations but we have some capabilities to implement more event solvers later on down the line as we
fully configure our model we can implement these additional solvers that may allow for non-uniform mass flows through the coil or conduction through
the fins in the heat exchanger so right now I'm going to go with that this fast solder which is appropriate for most applications to start now the principle
of working principle behind coil designer is that it is a finite control volume based model so that means is we're looking at a heat exchanger and we're breaking it into a large number of different control volumes and then
within each of these control volumes we're calculating energy and mass balances that propagates through all of the segments of the heat exchanger so to
specify our model we need to state the number of segments that we'll be dividing this heat exchanger into for
evaluation so we typically divide the heat exchanger up in terms of the number of segments per tube so you may have a heat exchanger with a large number of tubes will break each of those tubes
into several segments and solve those equations out in each segment here I'll start with a default of ten segments per tube and typically we recommend having
statements that are less than 10 centimeters each for good calculations and this is something that you can experiment with on your own to understand the trade-offs between speed
and accuracy as including more or less segments within your model so now I'm going to really begin
of outlining the geometry details of the heat exchanger that we are configuring here and the first step in that process
is defining the tubes of the heat exchanger so here we can have a heat exchanger that has inline tubes as shown in this diagram or staggered tubes and
we can go through the process of specifying the number of tubes and their dimensions so in this case for this
example I'll just begin with a heat exchanger that has 24 tubes per Bank as we call it this is in the transverse direction if we were looking at the face
of the coil see the number of tubes going upwards and then I'll specify two tube Bank and then this is the number of
rows in the in the air flow direction so here we have a 24 by 2 coil the next thing I'm going to do is enter the
dimensions of the tubes let's say that these are about a half a meter long and I want to demonstrate some of the capabilities of the software for a
smaller diameter tube heat exchangers so we will put in the details of a 5 millimeter tube coil now you can see here I'm entering my dimensions in
millimeters and that's because it's a setting that I've personally sat on on my system but this is something that can be customized by each user so that the
default values are in whatever units you prefer and the conversions can take place automatically within the interface so I'll go ahead and enter the dimensions between tubes the horizontal
and vertical spacing and then we have the ability to enter the details of the tubes internally as well so if we have smooth tubes we check this box here but
if we have enhanced or micro fin tubes we can enter all the geometry details that pertain to that to type so here I'll put in some dimensions for
five millimeter microphone tubes and all of these characteristics are defined in the drawing that I just pulled up there which you can access with this button
and with that we have entered all of the information that's required for specifying the geometry of the tubes and the next step is to move on to the
sentence so in this case I want to look at such a fiying the dimensions of the fins themselves so the thickness thickness of the fin and the sim density
and here we define that in terms of fins per inch which also that is 15 fins per inch and we have a number of options available to us for the type of sentence
so we can have flat plate fins we can have flip fins Lugar fins wavy fins or even just bear tubes that don't have any
fins on them in this case I'm going to pick a louvers in configuration and you can see when I select a fin type drawing pops up here on the right side that
tells me the dimensions that I need to enter to define that fin with this louver fin I know that this horizontal louver pitch is about one point six
millimeters and the height of the louvers is about one millimeter so I can enter those geometry details in here the
next thing I'm going to do is enter the refrigerant that's that's used in the heat exchanger and I have a lot of options here we support the refrigerants that are
derided the refrigerants that are in the mists rest prop database so you can see this drop down contains all of the working fluids that we typically
encounter in the HVAC industry as well as some other brines and water some natural refrigerants and and other
fluids and some some proprietary floats as well so we can select our in this case I just want to model r410a
so I can select that from the drop-down list and our exit our external fluid is air there's some more flexibility here if that's desired if you have a
proprietary fluid that we don't have yet in the software you can add your own fluid properties directly into the software and load that in or if you're
investigating mixtures you would even be able to define a user-defined mixture by specifying different constituent components here of different
refrigerants and a mass fraction for each of those so with these selections made I can move on to the final step of the initial setup of this coil and this is to select
the heat transfer and pressure drop correlations that are used in the calculation of the heat exchangers performance so this is really the foundation of Howell coil designer works
the calculations that it performs are based on empirical correlations that come out of the literature from various peer-reviewed papers where authors have
characterized the heat transfer and pressure drop performance of sins and tubes so to specify the performance of this heat exchanger it's important that I get accurate predictions if heat
transfer and pressure drop for the surfaces that we're working with so you saw before that I specified louver fins and I therefore need to select a
correlation on the air side that's appropriate for louver fins so when we drop down our list we can see that large number of correlations that are Verrill available for different skin types and
because we're talking about louver fins we move on to the these three options here that are that are that are given
for louvers and heat exchangers and one of these we know was recently developed at OTS specifically for small diameter tubes and heat exchangers so we're
building here a 5 millimeter coil so we're going to select this that is valid for the three to five millimeter tube diameter range so if I select this this correlation will be used to calculate heat transfer
coefficients on the air side clip these fins and I'll do the same thing on the pressure drop side I can use this off there's correlation to predict the air
side pressure drop for my small diameter louver finis exchanger and I'll follow through the same process for the tubes you saw that we specified micro fin
tubes for this coil so we want to select correlations that are valid for micro thin tubes as opposed to smooth tubes and I need to specify heat transfer and pressure drop correlations for each
phase of refrigerants liquid to phase or the vapor region so for the liquid and vapor phase in a two phase heat exchanger these these don't make a
enormous contribution towards the overall performance but we want to capture the performance nevertheless and here I'm going to pick a correlation that is specified for micro fin or
internally enhanced tubes so I can select that for my heat transfer coefficient for a liquid phase as well as vapor phase and I'll do the same
thing for pressure drop to specify a micro fin correlation for the liquid phase and the vapor phase and now finally I need to specify the
performance in the two-phase region and at this point we need to distinguish between whether or not we're modeling a condenser or an evaporator for this
particular model we're going to focus on a condenser and so from that I need to select correlations that are valid for a condenser now you can see we have correlations for evaporators
correlations for condensers some of these are very specialized they work specifically for co2 or specifically for ammonia in this case we want to find a correlation that is applicable for our
micros in tubes and for condensation so we'll select this correlation from Kalama and we'll do the same thing for the refrigerant pressure dropped into phase
and with this we've set up the fundamentals of the SI exchanger we've carefully gone through to consider the heat transfer and pressure drop performance for both surfaces and we now
have the framework to perform simulations with this heat exchanger I should also mention we have the flexibility to add your own correlations to customize or tune those correlations
based on lab data or CFD simulations so if the correlations that exist in the literature that are included on aren't applicable for your particular heat
exchanger type or aren't matching well with your lab data there's always room for customization of the total by by each user now after completing this
walkthrough I get the main screen showing me my my newly configured heat exchanger on the left side I can see a grid that represents if we were at in
the airflow direction looking at the face of the coil and the reason this is divided up into a grid is because we've specified in setting up this coil ten
segments along each tube and we have 24 tubes vertically and so this grid allows us to import air flow data so if we have
information from an experimenter from a CFD simulation we can specify different velocities temperatures relative humidities at different locations entering the face of the coil so it allows us to account for air flow of
mail distribution non-uniformity considering the tube side you can see we have arrows here on the last flowing from left to right and our tubes are
shown on the the center of the screen as if they were going into the screen and computer now these tubes right now are
are just you know a blank canvas and we can specify the circuitry however we like now that means I can go right into this interface and directly click to
define my circuitry by by clicking between any two tubes if I hold shift I get a connection on the opposite side
and I can set individual tubes as inlets or outlets in any pattern that that I like now for this example I'm just
working with a very simple counter flow circuitry so I can use one of the features within project generate circuits to automatically build this
circuitry so here I just want to have two counter flow circuits construction for this heat exchanger when I click OK that will generate this counter flow
configuration of circuitry where the flow comes in a tube 25 goes back and forth and down and crosses over at the middle of the heat exchanger and comes
back up and exits a tube member 1 and the same with this second circuit down below so now we've entered all of the geometry details of the heat exchanger
the circuitry the next step is to define the flow conditions that the heat exchanger is going to be experiencing so to do that I can go to project edit air
and refrigerant Inlet State and this is one place where I can very simply specify the overall air velocity and air flow conditions and the refrigerant flow
conditions coming in to the heat exchanger now I mentioned this would be a condenser so we want to specify a refrigerant state that makes sense for a
condenser the the software is able to model a condenser and evaporator or a single-phase heat exchanger but we need to specify operating conditions that
thermodynamically makes sense at that inland so for this condenser we would specify a pressure and temperature that is one can be any way to specify the
superheated vapor state that would typically enter a condenser and that means I can put in my pressure temperature and mass flow rate on the
refrigerant inlet side in this case I can specify that that would be about let's say two point seven mega Pascal's
and the refrigerant temperature is going to be about 322 Kelvin
which is 120 F and then we can set the refrigerant flow rate in this case about
28 grams per second on the air side we
can set the pressure the temperature and the relative humidity and then to
specify the air flow rate we can enter the air flow rate in in terms of volumetric flow rate here's one meter
cube per second or we can specify the velocity of the face of the coil so I'll go ahead and enter these conditions and
this will define our tube and fin heat exchanger and allow us to run a
simulation so when the simulation is completed these are what those results will look like and this is a dashboard that shows us the summary of how our
heat exchanger is performing so on the left side we have tabular outputs of all the performance information for this coil we have information about the heat load this is a condenser so it's all
sensible heat but we can look at the latent load or condensation it's a caesarian evaporator we have an estimate of the charge of refrigerant inside the
heat exchanger summary of the flow rate pressure drops on the air and refrigerant side as well as the outlet States for both fluids and some summary
information about the heat transfer area heat transfer coefficients that were calculated in the model as well as overall summary information about dimensions mass and we can put in our
own functions for cost if that's an objective for this exercise on the right side you can see a summary of some of
the performance shown graphically we can see the comparison between sensible and latent load we can see the visualization of the heat transfer coefficients of the different surfaces or we can see the refrigerant side heat transfer
coefficients are obviously larger than airside heat transfer coefficient and then we can see the distribution of the phases of refrigerant inside of this heat
exchanger and on a length basis we can see that a small amount of the heat exchanger is occupied by superheated vapor about half of it is occupied by two phase refrigerant and then about
half of it is occupied by some cold liquids so you know the state point we've specified here we can see is probably not as much mass flow as this heat exchanger could handle we have a
very large sub cooled region region and we could get more capacity out of it if we ran with a higher mass flow rate so these kind of tools are useful for making those kind of assessments to
understand what's happening in our model when we run a simulation and we can see these results in tabular form and we could look down even into very low level
details to see for example the temperatures or vapor quality at every segment of every tube and this allows us to do things like identify the location
where phase change occurs here we can see for example in tube number 24 there's a change of phase occurring and
we can explore exactly how the inner workings of our you can change your look there's additional plotting functionality here for understanding the
the distribution of heat load against tubes or temperatures along the coil face and we can see a visualization of
the temperatures on our heat exchanger and we can export all these results to excel or as a PDF for for storing that
information so this is already a fairly powerful tool for just simulating one given heat exchanger but we can continue this process and really use this as a
tool to aid in heat exchanger design so one of those functions I want to show here is the parent parametric analysis capability so if I go to project and
parametric analysis here I can define a parametric study where I can vary geometry parameters of the heat exchanger or flow conditions entering the heat
exchanger and and study the impacts that these different parameter changes have
on the models performance so the parametric analysis is up on my screen
here now and within here you can see various geometry parameters within the heat exchanger that we could alter we could apply different correction factors
to different correlation predictions and we could vary things like the air side Inlet conditions or the refrigerant stream conditions coming into the coil so just as an example I could look at
what happens when I change my fin density from 15 cents per inch up to 20
fins per inch for example and if I do something like this I can update my parametric table I can simulate my my
coil under these different conditions and I can quickly assess the impact of the performance change that occurs when I add greater fin density here you can
see I have an increase in heat load and an increase in pressure drop as they get more fins as we would expect but we can also extend this to multiplicative
studies where we look at different parameters in in combination so if I also want to study changing the two
blanks or the air flow conditions I can very quickly evaluate a large number of different designs within this interface and so there are some options here where we can look at individual pairings and
changing these values here we change the two blanks across the full range while keeping the simper inch the same and then we change the fin per inch while keeping the tube length the same we can
do a combination where we change both parameters at the same time or probably the more useful of these options is the multiplicative study which gives us every pairing of all of these different
combinations of parameters and we can easily think of thousands or tens of thousands of different combinations that we might want to evaluate for a heat exchanger and here you can see we can very rapidly evaluate all these different
combinations of heat exchanger designs and we can extend that even further he also may have noticed that on this simulation two results were showing up simultaneously and that's because we're
running these simulations in parallel here I've specified that I want to run two runs in parallel but if you could run this simulation on a workstation or server with larger number of processors you could conceivably run on large
number of cores and very quickly evaluate thousands of designs right
within this tool so with that we have a coil model built we have an assessment
of its performance and some studies of the effect of changing various parameters we also have the ability to
save this file when we go to save or save as we create a file called coil designer heat exchanger file the extension is dot chx and we can load
that back into coil design at any time and we can run the same evaluation same types of simulations and make modifications to it at a later date but we can also read that into our other
software zip psych which allows us to plug in that heat exchanger into an entire vapor compression cycle model this would allow us to simulate the impacts of multiple heat exchangers and
compressor design changes to evaluate a full heat pump or air conditioner or refrigeration cycle while maintaining all of the modeling details of one of
these very very detailed heat exchanger simulations so that is one of the other extensions of this of this tool is the ability of the ability to not just
evaluate the heat exchanger performance but also the entire cycles performance so very quickly I want to just demonstrate a microchannel heat
exchanger as well and walk through some of the steps for configuring that just
to demonstrate the
the concept very priestly alright so here again you can see another blank
coil designer file or interface and here we can start a new coil file again but this time we want to make a microchannel heat exchanger and we have the ability
to do a microchannel coil that has headers or one that is serpentine configuration whereas it's a continuous
continuous micro channel - that's bent between the different tubes vertically here I'm going to look at a channel that
has headers again we can set the solver information and the number of segments and we can go ahead and enter the information about the tubes so you can
see the interface is very much the same we have a a2 configuration and then fin and refrigerant the same process is
followed for this particular design I want to look at something with let's say a 12 millimeter vertical spacing between
tubes and the tubes here are 20 millimeters wide and 2 millimeters tall let's just say they have one millimeter
ports with 15 ports per tube and you can see this that we can specify a rectangular ports but we can also put in circular ports or we can enter additional information about the
hydraulic diameter if we have some non rectangular or non circular geometry we can account for the performance of that
by entering the hydraulic diameter and cross sectional area of important the next step is to enter the information
about the fins again and here I can set my fin thickness and fin density and with the louvers there with the microchannel heat exchanger we typically
see louver fins applied and we can enter the geometry for the lure fans and very much the same way as we can with the tube fin
interface so I'll just go ahead and leave the default values for now for the geometry of the fins for the refrigerant again we have the same flexibility of
different refrigerants here we'll just select r134a and then finally I'll go through this process of selecting appropriate correlations where we'll
select a correlation on the air side that is suitable for louver fins will select correlations for liquid phase and vapor phase refrigerant that he would
see in any heat transfer or fluids textbook for the single phase heat transfer and correlation and pressure drop correlations have selected and then
in this case let's make this an evaporator so I'll select a correlation that is appropriate for an evaporator
here the correlation from sha for the heat transfer coefficient and or recent
correlation or pressure drop in the evaporator so just like that we've configured our micro channel evaporator and you can see the interface is very
similar to the tube and fin interface but here in the center of our screen we have our micro Channel tubes which are going into the screen and the individual
ports that are inside of each of these tubes so we have the ability to specify really any header configuration we could
imagine here so we could have multiple passes of the heat exchanger and we can do that by defiance by adding individual headers in a similar manner to how we add you might and outlet States for the
tube thin coil but we also have another process to speed up the reconfiguration of these if we go at a project and
define micro channel passes here we can specify multiple passes of the of the coil by the number of tubes and it will automatically generate the head is for us in this case I'll just look at
a single past configuration for simplicity when I say okay that'll generate my header configuration here you can see in the front of the screen here in red that's my Inlet header and
the back of the screen in blue that's the outlet header and then to try this one out we can enter the air and
refrigerant Inlet state again and again this is the same interface as we see in tubing sin but since we're working with an evaporator in this case and not a condenser we need to specify an inlet
condition that makes sense for an evaporator so in an evaporator we typically have two phase refrigerant entering and so I can specify here
saturation temperature or an evaporation temperature as it might be called and the vapor quality the percent vapor quality at the inlet to the evaporator
and then I can set the refrigerant mass flow rate and the same conditions with the same conditions apply with the inlet
air let's say that we're going to operate with 27 degrees C pair with the seven degrees C separating temperature with this information I should be able
to simulate this coil and get a
prediction of of its performance and here's a look at my overall heat
exchanger performance you can see again very essentially identical display to
the tips to the tube and fin interface so with that I think I have covered the main features I'd like to include in
this demonstration for both the tube and fin and the micro channel interface within coil designer and I'll go ahead and give a couple of minutes if anyone
wants to submit additional questions through the chat feature I can review those and provide some feedback I'll go ahead and start reading through those at this time
so we received a couple of questions I'll start from from the top we have one question coming in about how to model tubes if they have different lengths
maybe one row has a different lengths and the second row this is something we would definitely encounter in something like a condenser coil outdoor unit that
that has a has a bend a you bend or an l-shaped Bend at this point we don't have a way to do that within the interface of the software and typically we just use the average length of the
two tubes and in general this gives it gives us predictions that are you know reasonably close to what we see in the
experiment there is a question about having multiple sub cooling lines or and I think that this this is really
answered by the customization of the circuitry I should a very simple circuitry here for this tube thin coil but conceivably we could have any number
of circuits defined here they could have different lengths and we can account for it you know that the the performance of each of those individual circuits based
on how we've defined them in the model we also have the ability to enter feeder tubes upstream of the coil so for each Inlet coming into the heat exchanger we
can specify a diameter and length of the tubes that feed it and there's another question asking if Rose has different
numbers of tubes how can that be modeled one option for doing that is to use plugged tubes so for example if I have in this this model that I've shown
previously where we have 24 tubes vertically if one of these tubes is it's the if one of these rows not have the same number of tubes so the second row
has less tubes than the first row I can make some of these tubes plugged so for example I can make this tube essentially
disappear and it won't and I can continue to do that to have a different number of tubes and that's about the level of flexibility that's that's available within an interface if
you want to have less tubes or more tubes in different rows you can block them off so that they're not simulated there's another question about leaving
again kind of leaving out a knotch for you know some some interference that's blocking flow and we can account for
that by specifying me the air air velocity profile that comes into the exchangers so if we have you know the assumption here is that everything is
uniform which is rarely the case but if we want to specify that some particular section of the coil doesn't receive air
flow in the same way that via the rest of the coil does we can we can reduce or eliminate them reduce the velocity of
the air that enters a particular segment so if you think of this as a grid we can specify any part of this this coil face area and reduce the velocity there too to represent
something more realistic as far as what is the real velocity distribution when you have all the blockages and non-uniformities that come from the enclosure where this coil is actually installed and so one place where we can
do that is within project edit airside parameters and this is an interface that lets us specify temperature relative humidity and velocity across this entire grid of course we're not going to do
that by hand but we have the ability to load and save files of this type so if you have data on your air flow distribution or you want to create with
something some template in Excel or you have data from CFD simulation we can go through here and load in an air flow profile that blocks off part of the coil or maybe it has a gradient where the top
of the coil sees a different velocity and then the bottom of the coil if we're talking about some type of enclosure or a coil configuration for example so we
have some flexibility there for how the air flow configuration is specified so I see one feedback saying someone's getting an error when trying to follow
my model I guess there must be some difference in the values that you entered and we're happy to answer those those questions through our support
email address which I'll go ahead and put up on the screen and this is one of
the features that is provided to our to our coil designer customers is technical support by our engineers at OTS we can
receive your heat exchanger files review them and and provide some guidance as to where where things may be going wrong in
in this case I think any number of entries in terms of geometry or correlations that don't don't match for the the particular heat exchanger that
we're looking at could could always you know yield yield errors and our staff is available to help provide that guidance
and in terms of fixing models that aren't working there's a question about
liquid overfeed coil simulation this is one I think I can take offline if you want to follow up with me by email we
can discuss that particular application further and there's a question about
tube orientation if the tubes are not horizontally oriented it is it's a good
question so in general we see that the gravity effects in most tubes and heat exchangers of the size range we see an
HVAC usually these effects are not extremely influential over the overall performance and we can get reasonable
results whether or not the tubes are oriented vertically or horizontally but fundamentally the question comes down to how the correlations were developed so
oil designer is really just based on these empirical models that authors have published for heat transfer and pressure drop performance in tubes and so some the majority of these authors develop
those correlations for tubes in a horizontal configuration but there's certainly literature out there that provides performance information for tubes that are vertically oriented and
so that's something that can be customized by an individual user you can add correction factors or add your own correlations if you find that you kind
of gravity effects from having vertical
tubes are are very significant and there's another great question about the selection of correlations I think it's
one of the most overwhelming features looking at the software there's a very large number of correlations that are
that are available to the user and it's often desirable to have some guidance or the selection of those right now we don't have any any summary document that
really something that provides guidance on a general selection for all options but we do offer as part of the licensing
technical support and training so each new user is entitled to training with with the OTS team and typically in those training sessions we go through
something like this demo process that we just saw today but we do it in a customized manner so we'll look at a particular coil that is of interest to
your company and we'll go through all the steps to model that validate that model and in that process kind of provides some guidance as to what type
of correlation is appropriate for your for your application and we try to train you through that process so that you can
internally develop some experience with the right selection correlations for your particular application because it can it can certainly very significant
from different fields and different product lines and manufacturers but it is something that we are working towards providing some more general guidance in
terms of the best correlations but often really making the best elections comes down to having having experience with the tool and end of and understanding of
experimental performance from from your particular product all right so I'll hang on a couple of minutes in case any more questions come
in but we'll be available to kind of work with you if you have any if you run into any issues if you want to contact
us at support email address I believe that all of our invitees to this session should have access to the software on a
temporary trial basis if you need to help with configuring that you can reach out to us at the same email address and then for any other additional kind of
sales questions about the software the trial license you can calm so you can
contact Tom drache I'll leave these up for a couple minutes and wait if anyone has additional questions but otherwise
I'll thank you all for your time and we'll be in touch if we can provide any additional assistance with evaluating coil designer you
so I hadn't initially planned to offer that up there's a question coming in about watching this video again after this session is over I have recorded
this session so I can look into whether or not we can we can host that on our YouTube page or something beyond that we also have another demonstration from our
third webinar for the ICA educational series and part of that webinar includes a demonstration of tubes in coil in coil
designer and that is also up so we'll try to follow up with everyone to provide some some additional materials for review after the sessions over you
all right everyone it looks like that's the extent of the questions that are coming in again you can contact us by email and appreciate everyone everyone's
time for joining and look forward to hearing from you in the future thanks again
Loading video analysis...