Ditch the DSLR? The 200-year-old science of my new favorite camera (2^14 sub special!)
By AlphaPhoenix
Summary
## Key takeaways - **Giant Cyanotype Camera Builds**: Instead of a tiny phone camera, this project built an exceedingly large analog camera that exposes on 11x15" sheets of paper, taking about a day to capture a single photograph. [00:25] - **Cyanotype: 1842 Blueprint Chemistry**: The cyanotype process, originally created in 1842 by Sir John Herschel for reproducing drawings, uses light-sensitive chemical reactions to create images, unlike modern digital cameras. [01:40], [01:55] - **DIY Camera Challenges: Focus & Exposure**: Building a large cyanotype camera presented challenges like significant spherical aberration, focusing difficulties, and a painfully low effective ISO of 0.00046, leading to exposures over 16 hours. [00:49], [12:44] - **Prussian Blue Formation**: The cyanotype's yellow sensitizer transforms into Prussian blue pigment when exposed to ultraviolet light, a process involving a complex cubic crystal lattice with iron in two oxidation states. [06:40], [06:48] - **Camera vs. Print Making**: The core difference between making cyanotype prints and exposing a photograph lies in how light is directed: physical masks block light for prints, while a lens focuses light to form an image in a camera. [08:45] - **Fire Hazard from Focused Sunlight**: Direct sunlight hitting the camera's lens can be focused, creating a risk of the photographic paper or camera materials igniting, prompting the photographer to pull the camera early. [16:10]
Topics Covered
- The Counterintuitive Journey of Analog Photography
- Cyanotype: An Accidental Photographic Chemistry
- The Hidden Dangers in Old Chemical Processes
- Why a Giant Camera Requires Days, Not Seconds, to Expose
- Embracing Imperfection: The Art of Slow, Flawed Photography
Full Transcript
digital cameras are getting smaller and
smaller
you're watching me right now on this
sony mirrorless that's
you know probably about the size of my
hand which is
pretty respectable but then there's also
this gopro that i film with it's this
tiny little cube
and then my phone camera which is
basically a little speck
hiding behind this aperture at the other
end of the spectrum
we have
this which i just built and this is an
exceedingly
large camera i figured that if my first
foray into analog photography was worth
doing
it was worth overdoing so you feed this
camera
entire sheets of sensitized paper and
11 by 15 posters exit the camera
ready to hang on the wall there are a
few quirks about this camera that i'm
going to get into
in a few minutes notably a painfully
painfully low
effective iso a significant spherical
aberration
and focusing problems and also a wee bit
of a tendency to light itself on fire
but all of that aside i have had great
fun with this project and i expect to
take
a great many more pictures using this
camera
[Music]
the first step in making a camera is
creating a light sensitive element
modern cameras use electronic pixels
that create an electronic signal
proportional to the amount of light
shining on them
but old cameras analog cameras use
light sensitive chemical reactions the
process i'm going to be showing you
today
isn't actually really a photographic
technique but a print making technique
it was never really intended to be used
in a camera like this just to make
photographic prints from film negatives
it's called the cyanotype or blueprint
process and it was originally created by
sir john herschel in 1842 as a method
for reproducing drawings
like oh yeah i want to make this book
about astronomy but i need a way to
you know recreate pictures rapidly why
don't i invent an entirely new
photographic chemistry just so that i
can do that
scientists back then were a different
breed his recipe was
basically untouched until very recently
all of the old like
blueprints architectural drawings that
you've seen used herschel's original
recipe
today i'm going to be using a slightly
modernized version that exposes a little
faster
from mike ware today we are making
a cyanotype camera first step in making
that
is mixing cyanotype solution
which contains cyanide
counter-intuitively
the cyanide isn't actually the toxic
part
because despite grinding the potassium
ferric cyanide into a fine inhalable
powder
the cyanide ion is trapped inside the
fairy cyanide ion and then
bonded to a metal it's not the hydrogen
cyanide that you know spies keep in
their teeth or
the doctor gave to dr air away before
the voyage in contact
no the the most worrying thing about
this is that there's like
sort of a yellow stain which i believe
is the ammonium dichromate leaking out
which is just lovely
that and the fact that they use degrees
fahrenheit in the recipe
just fill me with confidence the most
toxic thing in this recipe is actually
the ammonium iron iii oxalate
which starts as these lovely blue green
crystals that
somehow remind me of something when you
mix these three chemicals together
overheat and then let the solution cool
potassium iron iii oxalate precipitates
out
this would yield about 33 milliliters
of fluid and the rest would be discussed
in green sludge
and you can filter it away as these
slightly less
lime green and more forest green
crystals
wow that's really cool that's beautiful
there's your green sludge
it's crystallized out of course me the
material scientist
is always excited about crystals but
once you get rid of them
you're left with a bottle of sort of a
yellow colored liquid
that when exposed to ultraviolet light
turns into a vibrant blue
referring to this as a dark room
is pretty generous it doesn't really
block out very much light
but on the other hand the cyanotype
process isn't really all that
photosensitive
so it might work anyway so i've been
keeping the sensitizer in here is that
on camera yeah
inside of a completely closed box that i
even put a lid over to stop straight
light coming in
so i'm hoping that this is not yet you
know used up
yep still a yellow green color of course
you you can't see that on that camera
but i swear it's a
sort of clearish yellow green then this
is just citric acid
this is now clean so i'm going to get
probably
a pretty good syringe full of this
syringe but i don't know pipette
cool now we need a little bit of
citric acid so mix this up i'm not sure
this is going to come across on camera
at all
because it's white because it's like a
greenish liquid on
white but here i'm using a glass
stirring rod to spread the solution so
that i don't waste any
especially since i only ever coat one
piece of paper at a time
if i was using a brush a lot of
sensitizer would just get stuck in the
brush and would be wasted so
the glass is an interesting workaround
oh that's so infinitely better than when
i tried this a week ago
a little bit of practice goes a long way
if you want to make a blueprint-esque
image using cyanotype paper
you first need to create a mask here i
have a transparency sheet and i'm
writing on it in black sharpie because
ultraviolet light is going to go through
the transparency sheet
but ultraviolet light is not going to go
through the sharpie
this one gets this clipped to it
and there we go
okay so the first time i tried this
about a week ago as a test
it was mind-bogglingly fast the thing
exposed in less than a minute
it's a lot brighter today so i think it
might be even faster
there we go
that's like instantaneous
wow the yellow sensitizer solution is
being transformed by the ultraviolet
light
into a pigment chemical called prussian
blue
because i'm a material science nerd i
have to point out that prussian blue is
a really cool structure
that was just a couple seconds
iron fairy cyanide where the fairy
cyanide ion
made of iron and cyanide looks like this
big 3d cross
and it's stuck together at its ends by
more iron
into this cubic crystal lattice the
crazy thing is that this structure has
iron in it with
two different oxidation states and i
think it's actually electrons jumping
back and forth between these two
different irons that allows the dye
to absorb red orange light at 680
nanometers
which has the result of making it look
very blue
so check this out me take the
transparency off
and the text is unexposed you can see
that part of the pigment reacted to the
light and part of it didn't
it's got the dirty bath on the left
dirty bath at least do it in two steps i
figure
critically this crystallized prussian
blue
is not water soluble but the original
yellow sensitizer solution
is that means that we can wash the
exposed paper in water
to get rid of the excess sensitizer but
the exposed regions remain blue
so we're left with a negative blue white
image of our mask
that worked really well
oh yeah clip it up to dry
if you want more precision say you
wanted to make a design like a youtube
play button that says 2 to the 14
subscribers
you can actually print out an image on a
transparency
expose through that printed mask and
then wash it to get
really great crisp lines of course in
this case an inkjet printer on plastic
causes a lot of smudging so you know
maybe less than perfect lines at this
point you may be yelling at your screen
he's making prints this isn't a camera
the thumbnail had a camera in it
the only difference between making
prints
and actually exposing a photograph is
how you decide
which areas of the paper get more light
and less light
so far i've been using a physical mask
that blocks light from reaching certain
parts of the paper and lets the light
through in other places to turn the
paper blue
but what if instead i used a lens a lens
basically takes all the light coming in
from one direction
and focuses it to a single point then
all the light from a different direction
comes and it's focused at another point
and so on so if you focus a lens against
a flat surface
you can actually make an image where
every spot in that image
is made from light that approaches the
lens from a slightly different direction
and guess what now we have some parts of
a piece of paper that are receiving more
light
than other parts of a piece of paper we
can make a print out of this
so i embarked on constructing a very
large camera
man settlements you could use a brand
new
saw and a piece of mdf that cuts like
butter for a camera you need
first a way to hold the sensitized paper
or film
a lens to create an image on that film
and then a shroud to stop extra light
from reaching the photosensitive paper
all of the light in the camera should
have to pass through the lens and
contribute
to image formation i designed the setup
in cad printed out some parts
and attached everything to a slide arm
that fits on my largest tripod
the paper is clipped to some mdf in the
back that i've painted black to minimize
reflections
and the lens chucks into a 3d printed
jig in the front
there's an additional story here i don't
have time to tell completely where my
really cheap 500 millimeter lens was
actually more like a 550 millimeter lens
and then i forgot that focusing on close
things made the distance even longer
so basically i built everything too
short and i needed to make some
modifications
but in the end it worked the shroud was
by far the most tedious part to
construct and it's basically just a
whole lot of black poster board
that's cut creased and hot glued
together so that it
completely envelops the lens and
paper holder assembly letting no light
pass in
there's a 3d printed sort of sleeve in
the front
that actually allows the hood to slide
down over the lens holder
quite securely it's kind of weird
because you have to look away from the
thing you're photographing to line it up
and the image is all upside down and
backwards because of the way that the
lens focuses it
but the bigger issue is spherical
aberration spherical aberration
is a real pain the tree is in focus
and the house is no longer in focus and
then i tilt back
and the house is in focus and the tree
isn't like it's it's this much of the
image
now most film is tiny so you put your
film here and it would be in super sharp
focus and you'd have no problems
but i wanted to make big prints i wanted
to put a whole sheet of paper in here at
once
i could improve the focus dramatically
by cranking down the aperture using a
smaller diameter lens or just covering
up parts of this lens
but unfortunately that will also make it
take
much longer to expose and as it turns
out
exposure timing is is already a problem
in order to originally calibrate the
exposure time on this camera
i set a piece of paper down in direct
sunlight which i knew would expose in
you know 30 to 60 seconds and
i pointed a camera at that and i used
the camera as basically a light meter to
tell me how bright that piece of paper
was for point of comparison i did the
same thing
inside the camera i put the same piece
of white paper in the camera
and i pointed the camera at the sky and
then i took a picture of the paper in
the camera through the viewfinder
in order to figure out how bright that
paper looked
when it was illuminated by the sky and
unfortunately
it was really really dim so it turns out
that i have made a grave mistake
one exposure on this camera would take
over 16 hours with the brightest thing
in the picture
being the sky i did the math earlier
that is an effective iso
of 0.00046
so as opposed to like an iso of 100 or
an iso of 1600
no we go down by like seven orders of
magnitude
the first picture that i took only
exposed for about two hours and the palm
tree that i was photographing
was moving back and forth in the wind a
lot so while it was a good test
and upon washing i got an image that
image was both
very faint and very blurry the next shot
that i took was a picture of our roof
sun is about to set the sky is not as
bright as it normally is
at least not during the middle of the
day so i'm going to pull the camera
there is some manner of image there here
were a bunch of vents and skylight heads
and stuff like that and i was hoping to
see how much
detail i can capture at least near the
middle the image
in the viewfinder looked extremely sharp
this is my print of the roof of the
house
there's a lot of detail here um which is
very nice
but i was really hoping for for more
crispness than that because i know that
the actual image projected onto the
paper was sharper than that
so i'm trying to figure out what the
issue is i'm pretty sure that when i
pulled this paper off of the well
i guess it would have been upside down i
think that due to humidity or
you know heat or whatever it was
actually buckled out in the middle
like that a little bit so basically the
center was too close to the lens and i
think it just
straight up came out of focus so i want
to be able to press the whole sheet
flat while i'm exposing and to do that
i have a sheet of acrylic but i need to
make sure
that acrylic is going to be transparent
to ultraviolet light
it really doesn't matter how quickly
this exposes i just want to see how it
exposes differently
the part that's under the acrylic versus
the part that's not under the acrylic
so i'm not even going to bother to time
this i just want to see it turn blue
it's not looking good oh nuts
knowing that the cyanotype chemistry is
sensitive to ultraviolet not
visible i decided to run a test and i'm
really glad that i did
well you know once it dries that'll be
about fully exposed
and this is somewhere down there so i
lose about half of my ultraviolet when i
go through that piece of
acrylic instead i just decided to tape
all the way around the perimeter of the
paper it kind of hurts
because i really enjoyed having the
binder clips on it because they leave a
mark
and i really love when you can look at
something and immediately know how that
thing was made
and with tape it's a little less obvious
of course with a day or two of exposure
time per image
my options for taking photographs around
town with this camera
are limited so the third picture that i
took
was drum roll please the front of the
house
there were two added complexities with
this one first
i was worried about the camera being
disturbed by pedestrian which meant that
all day i was sort of leaning out the
window to check on the camera
but second the camera was pointed
generally south
which meant that direct sunlight could
at certain times of the day
hit this lens this is bad news because
if the sun were to actually get focused
to a point by that lens
the paper the actual photographic paper
or the black poster board that the
camera was made of
would get hot and run the risk of
starting a fire
i actually ended up pulling the camera
late in the day because i was paranoid
that the sun was shining into the camera
oh that's getting brighter okay yeah i
need to be done
darn it but that turned out to be a bad
call for the quality of the image
there's a lot of blue coming out man
you can't see much of the house i'm
disappointed
it needed a longer exposure that's
amazing
it needs like two days basically got the
driveway in the sky
the last picture that i took before
making this video was on an
unfortunately windy day but i basically
just
abandoned the camera in a parking garage
on campus
over the weekend pointed northeast into
the mountains
i arrived just after sunrise to set up
the camera
and came back to retrieve it late that
night despite the trees blurring out in
the wind i really love this shot because
you can make out the sky
the mountains the trees and the
foreground all independently
it felt like a very real photograph
despite being kind of blurry
now it's hanging by our front door
opposite the pale blue dot
and the roof texture shot is in the
living room next to bender and 3po
unlike most of my projects where i'm
sort of completely finished with it
before publishing a video
this time i know that i'm going to keep
using this camera because it's a pile of
fun
i really like the images that i'm
getting out of it and the technical
challenge of trying to improve the
process
is just wonderful so if anybody has any
suggestions about things that i should
take pictures of
or things that i could do to make the
camera even better
i would be all ears so leave comments
below
thanks for watching
[Applause]
[Music]
so
[Music]
you
Loading video analysis...