The Electrified Skies: Battery Design Challenges for Electric Aircraft
By EE Journal
Summary
Topics Covered
- Model-Based Design: Unifying Thermal, Electrical, and Mechanical Systems
- Energy Accounting: The Make-or-Break Constraint of Electric Flight
- Safety Requires Simulating the Abnormal, Not Just the Normal
- A Cleaner Path: Electrochemical Lithium Recovery Without Harsh Chemicals
Full Transcript
[music] Hello there everyone.
Welcome to episode number 664 of this here electronic engineering podcast called Amelia's Weekly Fish Fry.
Brought to you by ejournal.com and written, produced, and hosted by yours truly, Amelia Dalton. How should
we start off this 2026 season of Fish Fry? Talking about my all-time favorite
Fry? Talking about my all-time favorite topic, electric aircraft. This week, we are investigating the challenges of designing batteries for electric
aircraft with my guest Dr. Graham Dudgeon from Math Works. Graham has some really great insights on how modeling
and simulation are helping aerospace engineers tackle the thermal, electrical, and mechanical complexities
of these cuttingedge power systems. Graham and I also chat about how computational tools map to the technology development cycle and why
simulating abnormal conditions is crucial for meeting strict aerospace safety requirements.
Also this week I check out a new breakthrough in lithium recycling that could turn battery waste into new
lithium feed stock.
So without further ado, please welcome Graham to Fish Fry. Hi Graham, thank you so much for joining me.
Thank you for having me Amelia.
Absolutely. Okay, so first, how does mapping computational tools to the technology development cycles help engineers make better decisions at these
different stages of development?
Yeah. So if we look at the development of a technology specifically an innovative technology like electric aircraft or you know EV tall electric
vertical takeoff and landing because they're highly innovative you are asking different questions at different stages and one of the most fundamental
questions you ask is is this technology feasible so down at the earliest stages you're looking at the feasibility and the questions you're asking there Amelia
for relatively high level. How much
energy do I need to move this piece of equipment from point A to point B? What
types of losses might I expect? And how
might that have a bearing on the energy in the system? Because I have to carry that energy with me if I'm moving through the air from point A to point B.
It's an enclosed system. We can't
refuel. And so we're looking at the energy. Energy is fundamentally
energy. Energy is fundamentally important. And when we've answered those
important. And when we've answered those feasibility questions, we then start moving to more detailed technical design. And as we're moving through that
design. And as we're moving through that development cycle, different engineers are coming to bear and they're asking different questions. So for example,
different questions. So for example, we're thinking about the motor drives that are powering the propellers. We're
looking at the selection of the motor.
Is it a permanent magnet synchronous machine? Is it an induction motor? And
machine? Is it an induction motor? And
that has a bearing as well on the control strategies. So you really want
control strategies. So you really want to do as you move through this technology development cycle is get the fidelity of your simulation correct so
that you can answer those questions as effectively as you can at each stage.
So Graham, specific for aerospace engineers, how do these engineers bring together thermal, electrical, and mechanical systems all into one single
model?
Right. So you've touched upon one of the the core values of what math works offers engineers in terms of tools to
develop technology. We call this
develop technology. We call this modelbased design. So number one is to
modelbased design. So number one is to provide an environment upon which you can model your system in a single environment with all the appropriate
technology aspects. You know and as you
technology aspects. You know and as you point out thermal the heat generated is an important aspect. The electrical
aspect of course for electrical aircraft and the mechanical systems the the motors themselves are driving the propellers. And so at MathWorks, we
propellers. And so at MathWorks, we offer what we call physical modeling tools which enable engineers to model those different elements depending on,
you know, the aspect of the design they're involved in. But then most importantly, you can bring it together into that single model. That single
model then becomes your source of truth.
Amelia, it's the foundation of your technology development cycle. And you're
sharing that model between the teams and those teams are interacting with that model doing what they need to do. And
because you have that fully integrated simulation model, everyone is on the same page and everyone is ultimately working towards the end goal of that technology.
That makes sense. So Graham, why is it important to measure overall energy needs when designing new aerospace equipment?
Energy is fundamental when you are moving an aircraft from point A to point B, particularly an electric aircraft because you have to carry the energy
source with you through that flight cycle. And there's no refueling option
cycle. And there's no refueling option either. And so when you're looking at
either. And so when you're looking at the full system, you need to account for every jewel in the system, whether it's mechanical friction, whether it's
electrical heat on the cables, whether it's um switching losses on your power electronics. Every time they turn on and
electronics. Every time they turn on and off, there's heat being generated. You
need to know exactly what that energy is. The energy to actually lift the
is. The energy to actually lift the aircraft itself. I'll give you a quick
aircraft itself. I'll give you a quick rundown of what it looks like for an electric veto vertical takeoff and landing Amelia. So what typically
landing Amelia. So what typically happens is hovering is very energy intensive and so when you take off vertically you're expending a great deal
of energy and many of the EV tall systems will then go to so-called wingborne mode. you know, they might
wingborne mode. you know, they might tilt their rotors, they'll have wings, and that's typically much more efficient. But then when you land, you
efficient. But then when you land, you are then again in hover mode, which is incredibly energyintensive. So you have
incredibly energyintensive. So you have these two peaks at the start and at the end of your flight cycle, and you need to know where every jewel goes because
you need to size that battery correctly so that you can go from point A to B as safely as you can. Can you explain how
modeling helps with battery sizing and battery thermal management especially in these aerospace systems?
Yeah, absolutely. It goes back to like the simple example I gave of the takeoff, the flight and the landing.
When we're looking at that as engineers, one simulation is not enough. You must
simulate as many of those scenarios as you can. And when you are doing that,
you can. And when you are doing that, Amelia, then with the appropriate level of fidelity in your battery model, which would be electrical and thermal, you're
seeing a number of attributes of operation. You're seeing how the battery
operation. You're seeing how the battery is draining. You're seeing voltage and
is draining. You're seeing voltage and current levels. You're seeing the heat,
current levels. You're seeing the heat, the heat that's being generated. And so
by simulating many scenarios, you get this broad view on the overall design space that you're interested in. And
when you have that broad view, you can then optimize your system so that it's the best it can be.
Why do you think aerospace engineers need to simulate both normal and abnormal operating conditions?
Safety is paramount, Amelia. So, you
know, if we think again about those flight cycles, you're taking off, you have a destination in mind, you're flying towards it, you know, you come into land. Now, a normal scenario is
into land. Now, a normal scenario is where everything works perfectly. An
abnormal scenario is where something less expected happens. It may be a motor failure. It may be a degradation in some
failure. It may be a degradation in some other component. Something that causes
other component. Something that causes you to change the nature of that flight profile. So it could be you have to land
profile. So it could be you have to land early and if you need to land early perhaps on a diminished capacity on your motors, you have to simulate that as you
design the system. You need to go through those contingencies. Maybe you
turn around and go back to where you started. There's a number of different
started. There's a number of different abnormal scenarios that you can check.
And the key here with a simulation model is to check as many of them as you can, if not all of them. Because if you're
able to check all anticipated abnormal scenarios, then you know that you've improved the overall safety of your system.
So how does this type of testing help identify or address aerospace safety requirements? So there are a number of
requirements? So there are a number of uh safety requirements of course with safety critical systems which um aerospace systems are and with math
works there's two aspects to this with a simulation model. There's the safety
simulation model. There's the safety aspects associated with the flight profiles itself and anticipated failure modes. So you can simulate those. So
modes. So you can simulate those. So
that's the overall operational aspects of that entire system. But another
aspect is the safety of the software and the software that you're developing, the algorithms you develop to control your aircraft, does that comply with the
relevant safety standards as well? And
so the code itself must also comply. And
so there's two aspects. We offer tools that help the engineers test the code in a rigorous fashion as per requirements
for safety. And you can also evaluate
for safety. And you can also evaluate the operation of your full system. So
you can look at both the normal and abnormal situations. So simulation prior
abnormal situations. So simulation prior to deployment of the actual vehicle for flight testing. So prior to that,
flight testing. So prior to that, there's an awful lot you can do with simulation to improve your overall system design and build your confidence that you're going to have a capable and
performant technology.
Fantastic. All right, Graham, it's time for your off-the-cuff question before I let you go. So, Graham, if you could have a meal with one person, alive or
dead, today, who would it be?
Always my wife. Always.
I love that. That's cute. All right.
Well, Graham, I think that's all I have time for today. Thank you so much for joining me, Amelia. It's a great pleasure as always.
Amelia. It's a great pleasure as always.
Thank you.
Have you heard about the new breakthrough in lithium recycling?
Okay, so we all know that lithium, a key component in just about everything these days, is expensive to mine and refine.
And even further, most existing recycling processes require substantial energy and chemicals. And then what you
get from that process is typically lithium carbonate, which then needs even more processing to become the reusable lithium hydroxide.
But if we're talking about lithium and dealing with lithium ion batteries, we also need to address black mass. So yes,
that does sound like a heavy metal album, but in this case, black mass is the powdery mix of materials that is created during the lithium ion recycling
process. Now, since lithium is in such
process. Now, since lithium is in such short supply, we need to get all of the lithium out of that black mass as
possible. And recently, engineers at
possible. And recently, engineers at Rice University have devised a cleaner method for recycling black mass. Rather
than using strong acids to smelt or dissolve the cathode materials, their novel approach involves recharging the
waste. So, the system developed at Rice
waste. So, the system developed at Rice University uses the same mechanism that charges a working battery, pulling
lithium ions out of the cathode to recover valuable materials from waste cathode substances.
The process is remarkably simple.
Lithium ions migrate across a thin membrane into a flowing water stream.
Simultaneously, a reaction at the counter electrode splits water to generate hydroxide. The lithium and
generate hydroxide. The lithium and hydroxide then combine in the water stream to form lithium hydroxide,
eliminating the need for harsh acids or additional chemicals. And get this, the
additional chemicals. And get this, the lithium hydroxide produced by this process was more than 99%
pure, which is clean enough to feed directly back into manufacturing. It was
also proved to be highly energy efficient and also showed both durability and scalability.
This process maintained an average lithium recovery rate of over 90% over 1,000 hours of continuous
operation. How Shang Wang, associate
operation. How Shang Wang, associate professor of chemical and biomolecular engineering and the co-corresponding author of this study explains the impact
of their study like this. Directly
producing high purity lithium hydroxide shortens the path back to new batteries.
That means fewer processing steps, lower waste, and a more resilient supply chain. From here, this research team's
chain. From here, this research team's immediate steps include scaling up the technology. This includes developing
technology. This includes developing higher area stacks, increasing the loading of the black mass and designing
more selective hydrophobic membranes.
And the overall goal with these improvements is to sustain high efficiency even at greater concentrations of lithium hydroxide.
Sibani Lisa Biswell, chair of Rice University's Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering and the senior author of this study, says this about
the future of their research. We've made
lithium extraction cleaner and simpler.
Now we can see the next bottleneck clearly, tackle concentration, and you unlock even better sustainability.
Super cool, right? So, if you'd like even more information about the stories covered in today's show, I have posted several links below the player on this
week's fish frying page on eejournal.com and in the description for this week's YouTube episode as well. Hey, have you
checked out EEJournal on social media yet? Well, you should. You can find us
yet? Well, you should. You can find us at facebook.com/ejournal.
at facebook.com/ejournal.
If LinkedIn is more your thing, you can follow us or me on LinkedIn. And we are also on blue skyocial and mastadon too.
And we have a YouTube channel, youtube.com/ejournal,
youtube.com/ejournal, folks. It is chalk full of all kinds of
folks. It is chalk full of all kinds of techie videos, including our very popular Chalk Talk webcast series hosted
by me and our animated series called Libbyy's Lab. And of course, you can
Libbyy's Lab. And of course, you can subscribe to our EEJ Journal YouTube channel as well. Thank you everyone for tuning in. If you know of any cool new
tuning in. If you know of any cool new technology or heck, you just want to chat, shoot me a line at Amelia, that's a meme li ajournal.com
or post a comment on [music] our forums on ejournal. for the week of January
on ejournal. for the week of January 9th 2026.
I'm Amelia Dalton and you've been fried.
Loading video analysis...