Why Critical Thinking Is Disappearing – The Rise of Collective Stupidity
By The Psyche
Summary
Topics Covered
- Algorithms Manufacture Consent
- Social Proof Fuels Collective Stupidity
- Schools Teach Obedience Not Thinking
- Confirmation Bias Traps Smart Minds
- Critical Thinking Risks Identity
Full Transcript
Imagine waking up one day to discover that most people around you no longer question anything. That the world has become so
anything. That the world has become so loud, so fast, and so saturated with information that the human mind, once a powerful tool for inquiry, discernment,
and growth, has dulled into passive acceptance. Think about that. Think what
acceptance. Think about that. Think what
happens to a society where critical thinking vanishes? Where the ability to
thinking vanishes? Where the ability to reason, challenge, and reflect is replaced by instant reactions, surface level opinions, and collective echo chambers. In this video, we are going to
chambers. In this video, we are going to uncover the disturbing truth behind the disappearance of critical thinking, and the dangerous rise of what some philosophers now call collective
stupidity. a phenomenon where masses of
stupidity. a phenomenon where masses of people adopt shallow thinking, blindly accept narratives and surrender their intellectual independence without even realizing it. And at the end of this
realizing it. And at the end of this journey, we will uncover the most powerful and urgent truth of all. One
that could determine whether we reclaim our minds or lose them entirely to a system designed to keep us comfortably numb. But before we dive deep, take a
numb. But before we dive deep, take a moment to subscribe to the channel, leave your like and share your thoughts in the comments. The content you're about to experience may challenge your
perceptions and even shake the very foundations of how you see the world.
Share this with those who dare to think and who still believe that truth is something worth seeking. Let's begin
with an uncomfortable truth. Thinking is
hard and in today's world, it's often discouraged. The modern environment
discouraged. The modern environment doesn't reward contemplation. It rewards
speed, emotional response, and conformity. And this isn't by accident.
conformity. And this isn't by accident.
From algorithms that feed you only what you want to hear to educational systems that prioritize memorization over exploration, society is actively conditioning us away from critical
thought. The philosopher Noam Chomsky
thought. The philosopher Noam Chomsky warned us about this decades ago. In his
analysis of media and propaganda, he explained how power structures rely on what he called the manufacturing of consent. In other words, when people are
consent. In other words, when people are trained to consume without questioning, to agree without understanding, they become easy to manage and even easier to deceive. Critical thinking, once
deceive. Critical thinking, once considered a fundamental human skill, is now seen as inconvenient. It gets in the way of outrage culture. It slows down
online debates. It challenges
online debates. It challenges ideologies. It dares to ask, "But is
ideologies. It dares to ask, "But is this really true?" And in a world obsessed with being right, simply asking that question is seen as dangerous. But
how did we get here? The problem runs deep. One of the key drivers is the
deep. One of the key drivers is the information overload we all experience daily. According to neuroscientist
daily. According to neuroscientist Daniel Levverin, the average person today processes five times more information per day than they did just a few decades ago. We are bombarded with
notifications, messages, breaking news, opinions, ads, and updates every waking moment. Our minds were not built for
moment. Our minds were not built for this kind of input. When the brain is overwhelmed, it shortcuts. It starts to rely on mental habits, cognitive biases,
and group think to navigate complexity.
Rather than evaluate ideas critically, it looks for cues from others, especially from peers, influencers, or perceived authorities. This is called
perceived authorities. This is called social proof. And while it's a natural
social proof. And while it's a natural survival mechanism, it can be easily manipulated. Think of how often you've
manipulated. Think of how often you've seen an online post with thousands of likes and comments and assumed it must be true or important. That's not reason speaking. That's a psychological
speaking. That's a psychological shortcut and it's one of the reasons collective stupidity spreads so easily.
Not because people are unintelligent, but because they're being conditioned to follow signals instead of reason.
Another disturbing trend is the decline of reading, especially deep reading.
Neuroscientist Maryanne Wolf describes how our brains are being rewired by digital media. We now skim more, jump
digital media. We now skim more, jump between tabs, and struggle to maintain focus on longer texts. But here's the catch. Critical thinking requires
catch. Critical thinking requires sustained attention. You cannot analyze,
sustained attention. You cannot analyze, reflect, or truly understand if your attention span is constantly fractured.
Ask yourself, when was the last time you read an entire article without checking your phone? When was the last time you
your phone? When was the last time you paused after hearing something provocative to think rather than react?
These small habits, once common, are vanishing. The late Carl Sean, one of
vanishing. The late Carl Sean, one of the great minds of the 20th century, once warned, "We live in a society exquisitly dependent on science and technology, in which hardly anyone knows
anything about science and technology."
His concern was not just ignorance, but the erosion of the ability to think critically about the systems we depend on. In a world full of opinions, hot
on. In a world full of opinions, hot takes, and ideological warfare, the greatest rebellion is the quiet act of thinking clearly. But the problem isn't
thinking clearly. But the problem isn't just technological or educational. It's
also emotional. Critical thinking is uncomfortable. It forces us to admit
uncomfortable. It forces us to admit that we don't know everything. It
challenges our egos. It can lead us into cognitive dissonance, where our cherished beliefs clash with new evidence. And in a culture that values
evidence. And in a culture that values certainty, confidence, and identity above all, this is deeply threatening.
So instead of thinking, we defend. We
retreat into our tribes. We repeat
mantras. We cancel. We avoid. We
memorize slogans instead of engaging in dialectic. The kind of honest Socratic
dialectic. The kind of honest Socratic dialogue that has powered philosophical evolution for millennia. What we are witnessing now is not just a decline in thinking. It's a social shift toward
thinking. It's a social shift toward mental laziness. And yet the
mental laziness. And yet the consequences are devastating because when people stop thinking, they stop questioning. And when people stop
questioning. And when people stop questioning, they become vulnerable to manipulation, to propaganda, to fear.
And the question we must all ask is this: Who benefits when a population no longer thinks for itself? Stay with me because what comes next will uncover just how deeply these forces are woven
into our daily lives and why reclaiming our capacity to think is not just a personal task but a moral responsibility. To understand the roots
responsibility. To understand the roots of this collective decline, we must look beyond the surface and trace how certain systems have evolved not to nurture
critical thought but to suppress it.
Let's begin with the education system.
John Taylor Gatau, an award-winning teacher and outspoken critic of traditional schooling, argued that modern education does not exist to create independent thinkers. In his
words, "The truth is that schools don't really teach anything except how to obey orders." Gatau claimed that compulsory
orders." Gatau claimed that compulsory schooling was designed during the industrial age not to enlighten students, but to prepare them for factory life, predictable, obedient, and
non-disruptive. Think about that.
non-disruptive. Think about that.
Instead of teaching how to think, we are taught what to think. From early ages, children are evaluated not on the originality or depth of their thoughts, but on their ability to memorize and
regurgitate. Conformity is rewarded.
regurgitate. Conformity is rewarded.
Curiosity is often treated as a distraction. And over time, the message
distraction. And over time, the message becomes clear. Follow the rules, color
becomes clear. Follow the rules, color inside the lines, and don't ask too many questions. This pattern doesn't end in
questions. This pattern doesn't end in school. It only intensifies in adult
school. It only intensifies in adult life. In the workplace, in media, even
life. In the workplace, in media, even in our friendships, we learn that speaking out, questioning consensus, or holding unpopular views can cost us. The
fear of social exclusion, of being labeled difficult or controversial is often enough to silence even our most pressing doubts, and so we stay quiet.
But silence over time becomes complicity. The psychologist Eric from
complicity. The psychologist Eric from observed this in his book Escape from Freedom where he explained how many people secretly want to surrender their freedom of thought because true freedom
comes with responsibility and responsibility can be terrifying.
Thinking for yourself means you can no longer blame others for your ignorance.
You can no longer take comfort in the crowd. You must face the uncertainty of
crowd. You must face the uncertainty of truth and that for many is too great a burden. So instead we choose comfort. We
burden. So instead we choose comfort. We
choose distraction. We choose simplicity over complexity. And in doing so, we
over complexity. And in doing so, we become easier to control. Social media
has accelerated this problem to unimaginable levels. What was once a
unimaginable levels. What was once a space for global connection has become a battlefield of opinion wars, outrage cycles, and algorithmic manipulation.
Every platform is designed to keep you scrolling reacting consuming not thinking. You are nudged constantly
thinking. You are nudged constantly toward content that confirms your beliefs. You are encouraged to respond
beliefs. You are encouraged to respond instantly, emotionally and often angrily. The platforms reward
angrily. The platforms reward engagement, not truth. They thrive on division, not understanding. And in the middle of all this noise, the voice of
reason is drowned out. Thoughtfulness
appears slow, weak, even irrelevant. Why
reflect when reacting is faster and earns more likes? Philosopher Marshall
McLuhan foresaw this in the 1960s. He
warned that the medium is the message, meaning that the way we receive information changes how we think.
Today's mediums encourage speed over depth, outrage over nuance, and certainty over humility. Even truth
itself has become distorted. In the age of misinformation, what is true often becomes less important than what is viral. People no longer evaluate the
viral. People no longer evaluate the merit of ideas based on evidence or logic. They judge them based on how many
logic. They judge them based on how many people agree. This is the tyranny of the
people agree. This is the tyranny of the majority in its most dangerous form. Not
political but cognitive. So where do we go from here? We begin by asking better questions. Questions that challenge the
questions. Questions that challenge the status quo. Questions that demand real
status quo. Questions that demand real answers, not slogans or statistics stripped of context. What are you being told to believe? Who benefits from that belief? What assumptions lie beneath
belief? What assumptions lie beneath your certainty? How often do you seek
your certainty? How often do you seek out opposing views not to attack them but to understand them? These are not easy questions but they are necessary because the antidote to collective
stupidity is not just intelligence. It
is courage. Courage to be wrong. Courage
to learn. Courage to admit that you don't know and to start the journey of knowing anyway. Socrates, one of the
knowing anyway. Socrates, one of the earliest champions of critical thinking, famously claimed, "The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing." This
was not self-deprecation.
It was an invitation to stay curious, to keep asking, and to remain intellectually humble in the face of a vast, mysterious world. And yet today,
humility is rare. Certainty is woripped.
Arrogance is mistaken for wisdom.
Everyone has an opinion, but few have understanding. Everyone wants to speak,
understanding. Everyone wants to speak, but few want to listen. The irony is that true thinkers are often quiet, observant, reserved. They know that
observant, reserved. They know that wisdom grows not from noise, but from silence, from contemplation, from deep engagement with complexity. And this is
precisely why critical thinkers are often outnumbered and ignored. In a
culture that rewards speed and spectacle, the slow process of thinking stands little chance. But it must not be abandoned. Because once you give up your
abandoned. Because once you give up your ability to think for yourself, you are no longer free. You are a puppet. Your
strings pulled by forces you do not see.
And let us be clear, those forces are not abstract. They are economic,
not abstract. They are economic, political, and cultural. They are the companies that profit from your addiction to mindless content. The
politicians who rely on your emotional reactions, the institutions that depend on your unquestioning obedience. But
when you reclaim your mind, everything changes. You become harder to
changes. You become harder to manipulate. You begin to see through the
manipulate. You begin to see through the illusion. You stop being a passive
illusion. You stop being a passive consumer of ideas and become an active seeker of truth. And in that act, however small, you light a fire. A fire
that has burned through history in philosophers scientists revolutionaries, and truthtellers who refuse to stop thinking. So the question now is this. Will you do the same? Stay
with me because in the next segment we will dig deeper into the psychology behind collective thinking. You'll
discover why even the most intelligent people fall into these traps and how the brain can be tricked into believing what it wants to be true instead of what is true. We're not done. In fact, the most
true. We're not done. In fact, the most important revelation is yet to come. To
truly understand the rise of collective stupidity, we need to explore the battlefield within the mind itself.
Despite our faith in logic, the truth is that the human brain is far more emotional than it is rational. We like
to believe we make decisions based on facts. But the reality is far more
facts. But the reality is far more complicated. In his groundbreaking work,
complicated. In his groundbreaking work, thinking fast and slow, Nobel Prizewinning psychologist Daniel Carnean showed that our brains operate using two
systems. One fast and instinctive, the other slow and deliberate. The fast
system is quick, automatic, emotional.
It jumps to conclusions, makes snap judgments, and conserves energy. The
slow system is thoughtful, analytical, cautious, but it requires effort. And
here lies the issue. In our high-speed, always on world, most people are stuck in fast mode. There is simply no time or will to slow down and think deeply. So,
we rely on huristics, stereotypes, and mental shortcuts that feel right but are often wrong. This is fertile ground for
often wrong. This is fertile ground for mass manipulation. politicians,
mass manipulation. politicians, marketers, media outlets, they all understand how to exploit our mental shortcuts. They package complex issues
shortcuts. They package complex issues into simple binaries. They use
emotionally charged language to bypass reason. They prime us with repeated
reason. They prime us with repeated narratives until we accept them as truth, not because we verified them, but because they feel familiar. And the
danger is once we accept something as true, our brains begin to defend that belief regardless of evidence. This is
known as confirmation bias and it's one of the most powerful cognitive traps in existence. Take a moment to think about
existence. Take a moment to think about your own beliefs. How often do you seek out evidence that contradicts them? How
often do you truly listen to opposing arguments rather than preparing your counterpoint? If you're honest, probably
counterpoint? If you're honest, probably not as often as you think. And that's
not a flaw. It's human nature. But it
becomes a problem when we're unaware of it. Another key concept is group think.
it. Another key concept is group think.
a psychological phenomenon where the desire for harmony or conformity in a group leads to irrational or dysfunctional decisions. It's been
dysfunctional decisions. It's been documented in everything from corporate disasters to historical atrocities.
People silence their doubts for the sake of unity. They choose consensus over
of unity. They choose consensus over truth. Social psychologist Irving Janis,
truth. Social psychologist Irving Janis, who coined the term, found that even highly intelligent, well-intentioned people can make catastrophic decisions when they suppress dissent and avoid
critical evaluation. Why? Because
critical evaluation. Why? Because
challenging the group feels unsafe.
Because going against the grain requires more than intelligence. It requires
integrity and courage. And yet history shows us that progress has always come from those who dared to think differently. Galileo, Darwin, Nietze,
differently. Galileo, Darwin, Nietze, Martin Luther King. They were all rejected, ridiculed, or attacked for their ideas. But they thought anyway,
their ideas. But they thought anyway, they spoke anyway. And their willingness to challenge the collective ignorance of their time shaped the world we live in today. But make no mistake, there is a
today. But make no mistake, there is a cost. To think critically in a society
cost. To think critically in a society that punishes doubt is an act of rebellion. You risk being misunderstood,
rebellion. You risk being misunderstood, ostracized, even hated. But you also gain something invaluable. Clarity,
self-respect, and the quiet power that comes from knowing that your beliefs are yours, not programmed into you. Let's
bring this closer to home. Why do so many of us feel lost, anxious, or unfulfilled, even with access to more information and technology than any generation before? The answer lies not
generation before? The answer lies not in what we have, but in what we've lost.
And one of the greatest losses is the habit of inner dialogue. the ability to sit with a question, explore it, and allow truth to emerge through reflection. We've outsourced our
reflection. We've outsourced our thinking to machines, to media, to public opinion. But no algorithm can
public opinion. But no algorithm can tell you what is true for you. No
trending topic can replace your inner voice. And no mass movement can
voice. And no mass movement can substitute for the quiet certainty of a well-examined belief. So what can we do?
well-examined belief. So what can we do?
We can start by cultivating awareness.
Awareness of our mental habits.
Awareness of the sources we consume.
Awareness of when we're thinking and when we're simply reacting. One powerful
practice is metacognition. Thinking
about our thinking. Ask yourself, what's influencing my opinion right now? Am I
open to being wrong? Am I engaging with this idea or just absorbing it passively? Another is the deliberate
passively? Another is the deliberate practice of dialectical thinking. The
ability to hold two opposing ideas in tension while exploring them. This is
not just intellectual flexibility. It's
mental strength. It allows you to go beyond binaries, beyond us versus them and into the realm where real understanding is born. The philosopher
Jidu Krishna Morti said, "To understand the immeasurable, the mind must be extraordinarily quiet, still. That
stillness so rare in our age is where the seeds of wisdom grow. But let us also speak plainly. Critical thinking is not something you acquire overnight. It
is a discipline. It requires reading, not just headlines, but books, full arguments, and nuanced thought. It
requires listening, not just to those you agree with, but especially to those you don't. It requires humility, the
you don't. It requires humility, the kind that accepts uncertainty as part of the path. And above all, it requires the
the path. And above all, it requires the rejection of intellectual laziness. If
something sounds too good to be true, it probably is. If everyone around you
probably is. If everyone around you believes something without question, that's your cue to pause. Not to rebel automatically, but to investigate honestly. In a time when ignorance is
honestly. In a time when ignorance is loud and confidence is often mistaken for competence, thinking deeply is not just a personal virtue. It's a public service. Because the future of any
service. Because the future of any society depends not on the volume of its opinions, but on the quality of its thought. And the most powerful change
thought. And the most powerful change begins not with mass movements, but with one person who chooses to think clearly in a world that doesn't. In the final part of this journey, we will reveal the
most important truth of all, the core reason why critical thinking is disappearing, and what you can do to not only resist this tide, but to become a light for others. What you're about to
hear could change the way you see your mind, your relationships, and your role in shaping the world. At the heart of this entire crisis, beneath the digital
noise, the failing institutions, the cultural polarization, there is something even more insidious. The real
reason critical thinking is disappearing is not because people are incapable of it, but because they are afraid of what it might reveal. To think critically is to risk everything that gives us
psychological safety, our identity, our beliefs, our tribe. And for many, those things are too precious to question. We
live in a time when identity has become sacred. People define themselves by
sacred. People define themselves by their opinions, their affiliations, their ideologies. To challenge an idea
their ideologies. To challenge an idea is now seen as a personal attack. But
this is precisely the illusion that destroys thought that we are our ideas.
You are not your political party. You
are not your religion. You are not your social group. You are a human being with
social group. You are a human being with the capacity to evolve, to learn, and to change. And that journey of evolution
change. And that journey of evolution begins the moment you detach your worth from your current beliefs. The final and most important truth is this. Critical
thinking is not just an intellectual skill. It is a spiritual act. It is the
skill. It is a spiritual act. It is the act of honoring truth over comfort, growth over certainty, and freedom over approval. It is the quiet decision to
approval. It is the quiet decision to live with your eyes open even when the light burns. Because once you start
light burns. Because once you start thinking critically, you begin to see the structures that surround you. The
systems of manipulation, the algorithms of control, the masks people wear. And
it can be overwhelming. It can even be painful. But it is real. And reality, no
painful. But it is real. And reality, no matter how uncomfortable, is the only foundation upon which true freedom can be built. As philosopher and
be built. As philosopher and psychologist Carl Jung once said, "People will do anything, no matter how absurd, to avoid facing their own
souls." And yet facing our inner world,
souls." And yet facing our inner world, our unconscious motives, our inherited beliefs, our cognitive traps is the very essence of thinking. Critical thinking
is not just about questioning the world.
It's about questioning yourself. It's
about asking why do I believe what I believe? Where did this idea come from?
believe? Where did this idea come from?
What parts of me are afraid to let go of it? When you ask those questions
it? When you ask those questions honestly, a new world opens. Not just a world of knowledge, but of wisdom. And
wisdom is what our society is starving for. In a culture addicted to quick
for. In a culture addicted to quick answers, wisdom invites deeper questions. In a system built on noise,
questions. In a system built on noise, wisdom offers silence. In an era of mass conformity, wisdom dares to be free.
This is your invitation not just to think, but to wake up, to stop living as a product of your environment and start becoming the architect of your mind.
Because no school, no system, no social media platform will do this for you. The
responsibility is yours alone. And when
you rise to it, something extraordinary happens. You begin to see with clarity.
happens. You begin to see with clarity.
You begin to feel what it's like to live in alignment with truth. Not borrowed
truth, not popular truth, but your own hard-earned truth. You begin to notice
hard-earned truth. You begin to notice when manipulation is being used against you. You start seeing the difference
you. You start seeing the difference between information and propaganda, between education and indoctrination, between connection and performance. And
most importantly, you begin to lead, not with noise, not with ego, but with depth. You become a light in a dark
depth. You become a light in a dark room, a voice of calm in a storm of outrage, a grounded thinker in a world of reactionaries. This is what the world
of reactionaries. This is what the world needs now more than ever. Not louder
voices, not sharper arguments, but deeper minds. Minds that are willing to
deeper minds. Minds that are willing to sit in complexity. Minds that are willing to say, "I don't know, but I'm willing to learn." Minds that are no longer seeking to win debates, but to
understand reality. If you want to
understand reality. If you want to change the world, start by changing the way you think. Not because it's easy, not because it's popular, but because it's right. The rise of collective
it's right. The rise of collective stupidity is not a cause. It's a
symptom. No symptom of fear, of fatigue, of a world too distracted to look inward. But every act of thinking
inward. But every act of thinking clearly pushes back against that tide.
Every moment you pause to reflect instead of react. Every time you ask a question instead of assuming the answer, every time you choose clarity over comfort, you reclaim your power. So as
we end this journey, remember the most revolutionary thing you can do in this moment is not to shout, not to conform, not to repeat, but to think. Let the
others sleepwalk through slogans and screens. Let them trade their freedom
screens. Let them trade their freedom for validation. But not you. You are
for validation. But not you. You are
awake now. And once you awaken, you can never go back. If this message resonated with you, share it. Not because it's trendy, but because it's necessary.
Leave a comment with your reflections, your doubts, your insights. Because
critical thinking doesn't grow in silence. It grows in dialogue. And if
silence. It grows in dialogue. And if
you're still with me, know this. You are
not alone. There is a quiet revolution happening, a movement not of noise, but of minds, not of outrage, but of awareness. And it begins every time one
awareness. And it begins every time one person chooses to ask the harder question. Let that person be you. Stay
question. Let that person be you. Stay
curious. Stay awake. And above all, keep thinking. Thanks for looking.
thinking. Thanks for looking.
Loading video analysis...